Phishing incident response: A guide for organizations

Why phishing incident response matters for every organization

Phishing remains one of the leading causes of security compromise across every industry. Even with strong email filtering, authentication controls, and awareness training, sophisticated phishing campaigns still find ways to reach inboxes. Attackers exploit trusted platforms, hijack vendor accounts, and impersonate executives to trick users into sharing credentials or transferring funds.

When a phishing email evades defenses, your team’s response determines whether it becomes a minor event or a costly breach. Fast, coordinated action limits lateral movement, data loss, and financial exposure.

This guide breaks down each phase of an effective phishing incident response program, highlights common organizational gaps, and outlines practical ways to modernize your workflows using automation and visibility from Sublime.

Main takeaways

• A phishing incident isn’t over when the email is reported; risk persists without a structured response.
• Phishing incident response must be fast, repeatable, and integrated across detection, investigation, and containment.
• Sublime helps SOC teams investigate, search historical email data, and remediate threats in a single platform.
• A mature phishing response strategy reduces dwell time, business impact, and analyst workload.

What is phishing incident response?

Phishing incident response is a structured process for investigating, containing, and mitigating phishing attempts after they are detected or reported. It applies to all phishing categories, including credential theft, business email compromise (BEC), malware delivery, and multi-channel phishing via email, SMS, or collaboration tools.

The goal is to minimize damage, restore operations quickly, and strengthen defenses to prevent recurrence. Given phishing’s role in most modern breaches, every SOC needs a well-defined, repeatable response workflow.

Why should organizations prepare for phishing incidents?

Phishing incidents can lead to major financial, operational, and reputational harm. Common impacts include:

• Financial losses: wire fraud, ransomware, or fraudulent vendor payments
• Compliance penalties: regulatory fines and breach disclosure costs
• Reputational damage: loss of customer trust and partner confidence
• Operational disruption: downtime, credential resets, and recovery costs
• Data breach expenses: legal investigations, forensics, and notifications

Preparedness, supported by a clear incident response plan, ensures your team can react decisively when an attack bypasses defenses.

Key phishing incident response roles and responsibilities

A strong phishing incident response program requires collaboration across technical and operational roles:

• Executive sponsor: allocates resources and approves escalations
• SOC analyst: leads investigation, triage, and technical remediation
• Incident coordinator: manages communication, documentation, and timing

Essential phishing incident response steps

1. Preparation

Preparation forms the backbone of a phishing incident response plan.

• Playbooks: define escalation paths, responsibilities, and communication protocols
• Technical controls: deploy layered defenses such as secure email gateways, endpoint detection and response (EDR), and sandboxing
• Training: equip response teams and end users to recognize and report phishing attempts
• Testing: run tabletop exercises and red-team simulations to validate readiness
• Tools: use automated analysis, SOAR integrations, and threat intelligence feeds

2. Detection and analysis

Detection and analysis define the scope and severity of a phishing incident. Analysts examine email headers and sender details to identify spoofing or domain mismatches, inspect URLs and attachments in sandbox environments to understand post-click behavior, and review user activity to confirm whether links were clicked or credentials were entered. Authentication logs, SIEM data, and identity telemetry help surface suspicious sign-ins, while network traffic analysis can reveal beaconing or signs of data exfiltration.

Automation is critical during this phase because it compresses investigation timelines. Tasks that often take analysts 30 to 60 minutes during manual triage can be completed in minutes with automated analysis. Identifying affected users, correlating logs, removing malicious emails from inboxes, and resetting compromised credentials all happen faster when visibility and remediation are centralized. The result is quicker containment, reduced dwell time, and significantly less operational strain on the SOC.

3. Containment and eradication

Containment should begin as soon as malicious activity is confirmed. Revoke compromised sessions, reset credentials, and remove all copies of the phishing email from user inboxes. Block associated domains, IP addresses, and indicators of compromise across email and network systems to stop further spread.

4. Recovery and user communication

After containment, restore normal operations while keeping users informed. Notify affected employees (resetting passwords as needed), reinforce phishing awareness, and clarify which actions to avoid. Validate that systems, accounts, and email flow have been safely restored.

5. Post-incident review

Once recovery is complete, conduct a post-incident review to capture lessons learned and improve future readiness. Document each action taken from detection through remediation, identify workflow gaps, and measure response performance using metrics such as mean time to detect (MTTD), mean time to respond (MTTR), and dwell time.

Respond to phishing faster with Sublime

Sublime enables SOC teams to search across historical and live email data, investigate phishing campaigns, and remediate malicious messages in seconds.

Teams gain full visibility into detection logic, historical lineage, and threat patterns – without vendor bottlenecks or opaque systems.

What to include in a phishing incident response plan

A phishing-specific response plan template should define:

• Clear ownership and escalation paths for each response phase
• Communication templates for users, leadership, and external stakeholders
• Integration points with SIEM, SOAR, and ticketing systems
• Regular testing and continuous improvement cycles

Key tools and data sources for phishing investigations

Effective phishing response depends on full visibility across data streams.

• Email metadata and message lineage: headers, timestamps, message authentication details, and delivery logs map sender infrastructure and campaign spread
• User behavior and access logs: SIEM or IAM data confirm user actions following a phishing email
• Threat intelligence and reputation data: validate domains and sending IPs, hashes, or campaign identifiers
• Sandbox and URL inspection tools: safely execute suspicious payloads and links to observe behavior

How to strengthen your phishing incident response program

1. Conduct structured post-incident reviews

After every incident, review what worked, what failed, and how long each phase took. Track metrics like MTTD, MTTR, number of affected users, and detection bypass rates to refine rules and workflows.

2. Build continuous feedback loops

Include stakeholders from security, IT, legal, and communications throughout and after incidents. Update playbooks, SIEM alerts, SOAR rules, and escalation criteria as phishing tactics evolve. Provide feedback to employees who report suspicious messages to reinforce awareness.

3. Stay ahead of emerging techniques

Attackers continually innovate. Update response playbooks to address:

• QR code phishing (URLs embedded in images)
• AI-generated spear phishing and impersonation
• Multi-channel phishing across email, SMS, and chat
• Supply chain compromises via trusted vendors
• Payload-less BEC attacks requiring behavioral analysis
• ICS calendar phishing 

4. Define response tiers

Establish response levels based on threat type, user interaction, and business impact.
Tiering streamlines triage and ensures consistent escalation.

5. Automate repetitive actions

Use Sublime or SOAR integrations to automatically remove malicious emails, block indicators, and notify users. Automation can reduce mean time to respond from hours to minutes.

6. Test readiness with phishing-specific simulations

Run tabletop and live-fire simulations to identify unclear ownership or slow response phases before a real attack occurs.

Protect email on your terms

Phishing, business email compromise, and alert fatigue continue to challenge traditional email security tools. Legacy systems often hide detection logic and delay response behind vendor support queues.

Sublime provides full visibility, explainability, and automation – empowering defenders to investigate, remediate, and adapt in real time. Security teams gain not just alerts but complete control.

Request a demo →